Amira Tutor™

AI Depth Score Rationale

The score should be 5 (AI-First) rather than 4 (AI-Centric). The evidence shows that Amira fundamentally could not exist without AI - it 'listens to every student read aloud, analyzing each word, diagnosing foundational skills' in real-time, which requires sophisticated speech recognition and NLP. The product is described as 'the learning agent' and uses 'neuroscience and AI' as its foundation. All three core components (Assess, Instruct, Tutor) are AI-powered: real-time oral reading analysis, AI instructional assistant for lesson planning, and one-to-one AI tutoring with real-time adaptive feedback. The product is explicitly positioned as an AI learning agent, not just AI-enhanced tutoring. This level of real-time speech analysis, diagnosis, and adaptive response is fundamentally AI-native and could not function without advanced AI - meeting the 'couldn't exist without AI' criterion for score 5.